An Open Response to Leonard Pitts' Attack on Twitter

Dear Mr. Pitts,

You’re not the first observer to express uncertainty about Twitter’s merits, and you won’t be the last. Your column was hardly a fresh perspective. But don’t worry, it’s a common malady with a common cure.

Like the hordes of half-informed columnists, busy executives and malcontents who came before you, your biggest mistake is that you took a cursory glance at Twitter and made a snap judgment.

Sure, if you judge Twitter by the Tweets of Ann Curry or Shaquile O’Neal, Twitter might seem frivolous. If you look only at the “I’m eating a hamburger” posts, you might get that impression, too. But what you missed in your fact gathering are the millions of people now using Twitter as a productivity tool.

Yes, Mr. Pitts, some people actually accomplish things via Twitter. We’re growing businesses, finding jobs, raising money for charity, planning conferences and engaging in ethics debates.

Rather than argue the point here on my blog, though, I’d like to make you an offer: Let’s talk.

The way I see it, this is a forest/trees situation. You’ve seen some of what’s happening on Twitter, but not all of it. Let me show you the rest.

We can communicate via whichever medium you’re most comfortable with: Telephone, e-mail, facsimile, CB radio — pick your poison. Still have those walkie-talkies you had in 4th grade?

I’ll admit this is an experiment. My self-interest in this is to put my powers of persuasion to the test. If I happen to open your eyes to a tool that makes your job easier, we’ll just call it gravy. Thousands of journalists use Twitter already, and it’s saving their careers. Let’s see what Twitter can do for Leonard Pitts. Heck, maybe you’ll even retract your “I will never Twitter you” promise.

Maybe.
 

Sincerely,

 

Scott Hepburn
Copywriter, Blogger, Twitter User

 

P.S. Right now, this post is being “ReTweeted” (forwarding, in email lingo) all over Twitter, driving traffic to your column. You’re welcome. I’m sure the Miami Herald’s advertising department appreciates Twitter today.

  • http://sandinmyswimsuit.com MissIve

    Hepburn, I love your style. I leave the 'man love' to @dannybrown, but seriously, loved this piece. You certainly live up to the hooligan title.

    And as for Twitter and what it “does,” all I can say is just that—it “does.” As in, unlike any other form of media I've experienced in my lifetime or career (ranging from journalist, snarky columnist (Hello, Pitt), blogger and copywriter), IT HAS AGENCY. It moves you places. It has a current. If you're not very, very careful, it will wash away all the jaded cynicism you've worked a lifetime to build up about “people.”

    Steer clear, Pitt. It's not for you. Very dangerous stuff.

    Thanks, Scott. Valiant.

    Miss Ive

  • http://dannybrown.me Danny Brown

    Just wanted to drop in an addendum to this.

    On Thursday March 19, the 12for12k Challenge supporters raised more than $13,000 in 12 hours via a charity tweet-a-thon. This was for Share Our Strength, which combats child hunger in the US.

    Put that into context:

    * Enough meals to feed almost 14,000 pre-school kids
    * Enough funds to allow more than 500,000 families to feed their kids during the school summer break.

    I hope Leonard Pitts is reading this, because I'd like to ask him when was the last time he fed 14,000 pre-schoolers or made a difference in the lives of over half a million families?

    Guess it's tough coming to terms with being irrelevant…

  • http://dannybrown.me Danny Brown

    Just wanted to drop in an addendum to this.

    On Thursday March 19, the 12for12k Challenge supporters raised more than $13,000 in 12 hours via a charity tweet-a-thon. This was for Share Our Strength, which combats child hunger in the US.

    Put that into context:

    * Enough meals to feed almost 14,000 pre-school kids
    * Enough funds to allow more than 500,000 families to feed their kids during the school summer break.

    I hope Leonard Pitts is reading this, because I'd like to ask him when was the last time he fed 14,000 pre-schoolers or made a difference in the lives of over half a million families?

    Guess it's tough coming to terms with being irrelevant…

  • http://dannybrown.me Danny Brown

    Just wanted to drop in an addendum to this.

    On Thursday March 19, the 12for12k Challenge supporters raised more than $13,000 in 12 hours via a charity tweet-a-thon. This was for Share Our Strength, which combats child hunger in the US.

    Put that into context:

    * Enough meals to feed almost 14,000 pre-school kids
    * Enough funds to allow more than 500,000 families to feed their kids during the school summer break.

    I hope Leonard Pitts is reading this, because I'd like to ask him when was the last time he fed 14,000 pre-schoolers or made a difference in the lives of over half a million families?

    Guess it's tough coming to terms with being irrelevant…

  • Pingback: Class Session for Wednesday, November 17th | Communication Studies 225

  • Pingback: Oh, Leonard! « Taking Aim